Conclusions and conundrums
The information that comes out of this framework and the other data sets is not always straightforward. Here are some things that strike us:
- Digital exclusion is BIG problem
For organisations that want to be more productive or deliver services online. Or just for people who want to live in a fair and equitable society. These numbers are big and they probably don't cover everything because, in the digital age, measuring digital capability in the non-digital population is really hard. So this may not even be the full picture.
- People can't up-skill properly in a piece-meal way
Nearly half the people learning new working skills do so self-taught from the internet. Only 6% get formal training through work. If we want the 52% to get up to speed, we all need to recognise there's a problem and tackle it in a systematic way.
- But it IS easier to learn digital skills if you've got digital skills.
You can search for a guide, watch a tutorial, join a forum. If you don't have the capacity to do this, you can't learn it online. The lower your skills and confidence, the more likely you are to want to learn from someone you know, in person, repeatedly.
Previously Lloyds reports have tracked people by skills level (from very low to very high). While the general trend is upward, it's worth noting that it was much harder to move up from the lowest levels than up between higher ones.
- People who don't have digital skills need other people to help them learn.
The way people like to learn digital skills flips as they age.
When people are 25-34, they prefer to investigate new digital skills through self-teaching. More than half of them do this ( 57%), compared to 18% who like to reach out to people with expertise.
This gradually changes, so by the time they are 65+, only a third want to investigate for themselves (31%) compared to 45% who want help from people with expertise.
As mentioned previously, age doesn't always track to digital ability but it is the key marker, so it's safe to assume, the less digitally confident you are, the more human help you need. These preferences around learning styles also track to gender, income, social grade, education and disability.
If we want these people to take part in a digital society, we need to help them in a systematic way.
- Inclusion isn't a one-hit solution.
Previous Lloyds reports also saw people occasionally moving down as well as up. While encouragingly, the figures for older people generally improve, that's not true for all age groups and there was a decline in some of the younger ones. It's hard to put this down to a single cause - factors like advances in technology and the cost of living crisis pay a role. But people don't just need a single course of tech skills. It's got to be an on-going process.
- It isn't going to fix itself.
More people are online than ever before. But people are still struggling profoundly as the world becomes digital first, or worse, digital only. From last year's EDS report to this one, the percentages of people who have the full sets of EDS has hardly changed. And the number of single skills that people have hasn't either. We won't get everyone living, working and thriving in a digital society but just hoping. We need consistent and concerted efforts.